New Construction vs. Resale in Central Ohio: Which Is the Better Buy Right Now?
New Construction vs. Resale in Central Ohio: Which Is the Better Buy Right Now?

Central Ohio continues to grow, and new neighborhoods keep going up in places like Delaware County, Union County, and the edges of Franklin County. With Freddie Mac's survey putting the average 30-year rate at 7.11% on November 12, 2026, builders and resale sellers are both competing hard for buyers. That makes it a good moment to compare the two side by side.
Where New Construction Shines
- Builder incentives: Many builders offer rate buydowns or closing cost help, especially through their preferred lender. When rates are high, these incentives can be worth more than a price cut.
- Lower maintenance early on: New roofs, furnaces, and appliances mean fewer repair costs in the first years.
- Builder warranties: Most new homes come with a warranty covering workmanship and major systems for set periods.
- Energy efficiency and modern layouts: Newer building standards and open floor plans appeal to many buyers.
Where Resale Homes Shine
- Established neighborhoods: Mature trees, finished landscaping, and close-in locations like Upper Arlington, Clintonville, and Worthington.
- More negotiating room right now: With 6,530 homes for sale in September, up 12.3% from a year earlier, many resale sellers are open to concessions.
- What you see is what you get: No construction delays and no upgrade decisions that add up quickly.
- Often lower costs beyond the price: Window treatments, landscaping, and fencing are frequently already in place.
New Construction Pitfalls to Watch For
- Base prices rarely include the finishes in the model home. Get a written list of what is included and price out upgrades early.
- The builder's sales agent represents the builder. Bring your own agent on your first visit, since many builders require it to be registered then.
- Compare the builder's lender incentive with outside quotes. Sometimes the incentive is worth it; sometimes a different lender is cheaper overall.
- Get your own inspections, ideally before drywall and again before closing, even on a brand-new home.
Ask about property taxes. New homes may carry a low tax bill until the finished home is fully assessed, and some developments have additional assessments.
Bottom Line
New construction offers builder incentives, warranties, and low early maintenance, while resale homes offer established neighborhoods and plenty of negotiating room this fall. The best choice depends on location and total cost, not just list price. Compare the full package, including incentives, upgrades, taxes, and closing costs, before deciding.
Margaret Lipp | REMAX Premier Choice
Serving Upper Arlington, Dublin, Worthington, Clintonville, Hilliard, Powell, Grandview, and all Central Ohio communities
Data source: Columbus REALTORS® Central Ohio Housing Report, September 2026, based on Columbus & Central Ohio Regional MLS residential data. Mortgage rate data: Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week of November 12, 2026. Payment examples show principal and interest only and are illustrative, not a loan quote. Consult a licensed lender for rates and terms. Builder incentives, warranties, and tax treatment vary by builder, community, and county.















